Blog · 14 November 2026

Nanny or Kindergarten: Which to Choose and When

Nanny or kindergarten in Moscow: pros and cons, the right age, 2026 costs and combined options. How families decide calmly and without guilt about the choice.

Nanny or Kindergarten: Which to Choose and When

"Nanny or kindergarten?" comes up in almost every Moscow family when a mother returns to work or a child turns two or three. There is no universal answer: it depends on the child's age and temperament, the parents' schedule, the budget and what the family expects from the next few years. Here is how to compare the options honestly.

What a nanny offers

A nanny works only with your child and follows your routine, while a kindergarten has one schedule for the whole group.

  • individual attention: activities, walks and naps are built around your child;
  • a flexible schedule — full day, live-in, a few days a week or on rotation;
  • fewer colds in the early years, since there is no daily contact with twenty children;
  • help with clubs, doctor visits, the child's laundry and meals;
  • a gentler transition: the child stays at home in familiar surroundings.

There are downsides. A nanny is a significant expense: in Moscow in 2026 a full-day nanny (5 days a week) costs roughly 140,000–200,000 RUB a month. Older children also need peers, so a nanny has to organise socialising — playgrounds, clubs, play groups.

What a kindergarten offers

  • daily contact with peers and group skills;
  • a structured day with lessons, music and sport;
  • state kindergartens are free, and private ones cost less than a full-day nanny;
  • gradual preparation for school routines.

But there are limits: fixed opening hours, frequent sick days in the first year, large groups and little individual attention. Many children under three find adjustment hard.

Choosing by age

Under 2

At this age a child needs one consistent adult more than a group. When a mother returns to work, families usually choose a full-day live-out nanny. More on this format: live-out nanny.

2–4 years

A borderline age. A sociable child may enjoy kindergarten; an anxious one may need more time. A good compromise is half a day in kindergarten and a nanny in the afternoon.

4–7 years

For most children kindergarten is already useful. If the family has high expectations for development, languages and school readiness, add a governess in the afternoons: governess for a preschooler.

Combined options

  • kindergarten in the morning, then the nanny picks the child up, feeds them, puts them down for a nap and takes them to clubs;
  • a full-day nanny plus a play group two or three times a week;
  • a nanny during kindergarten adjustment, staying close in the first days;
  • a nanny for sick days and holidays when the kindergarten is closed.

Questions to help you decide

  • How does your child cope with separation and new places?
  • How often do they get ill, and is the family ready for sick days?
  • How many hours of help do you need, including commuting time?
  • Who will take the child to clubs, doctors and friends' parties?
  • What budget is comfortable for the next two or three years?

If you choose a nanny

Define the tasks: schedule, duties, languages or teaching background. We meet every candidate in person: an interview, a detailed questionnaire and documents, calls to previous employers, checks against the blacklists of our agency network, and testing. Extended background checks are available at the family's request and with the candidate's separate consent. The family always makes the hiring decision — after an interview and a trial period.

Before starting, the candidate provides a medical record or health certificates. Additional tests are available at the family's request.

Comparing the real costs

To compare fairly, count the full cost, not just the monthly fee. Private kindergartens in Moscow often add fees for meals, clubs, a speech therapist and summer sessions. State kindergartens have few direct costs, but there are indirect ones: parents' sick days in the first year, taxis when the child has to be picked up early, help from grandparents or an hourly nanny during quarantines.

A nanny's costs are more predictable: the agreed salary, usually lunch during the working day and overtime pay. If the nanny also handles child-related chores — laundry, children's meals, tidying the nursery — parents save several hours a week.

Signs your child is ready for kindergarten

  • stays calmly with other adults for at least a couple of hours;
  • shows interest in other children at the playground;
  • eats independently and is close to being toilet trained;
  • can nap without being held;
  • can express needs in words or gestures.

If most of these do not yet apply, there is no need to worry — your child may simply be happier at home with a nanny for another six months or a year.

If you chose kindergarten but have doubts

Give adjustment time — usually two to six weeks. Start with a couple of hours, increase gradually and pick the child up before the nap in the first weeks. If after six to eight weeks the child still cries every morning, sleeps badly and is often ill, take a break, revisit the question in a few months and hire a nanny in the meantime.

Still unsure? Tell us about your child and schedule — we will suggest a format and send profiles. All options: nanny in Moscow.

Need help finding staff? Nanny City has been placing nannies and household staff in Moscow since 2003. Leave a request →

Read also

Need help finding the right person?

Leave a request — our manager will call you back and send candidate profiles.

Our specialists will reply to your request and advise you
Mon–Fri 9:00–18:00 (Moscow time)

Staffing request

We will call you back, clarify your needs and send candidate profiles.

Contacts

Visit our office in central Moscow or contact us any convenient way — the consultation is free. We speak English.

+7 925 000-73-37Call, WhatsApp or Telegram
Message us on WhatsAppWe can send candidate profiles straight to the chat
Arbat St. 54/2, bldg 1, office 411, Moscow4th floor, Smolenskaya metro station
Mon–Fri 9:00–18:00 (Moscow time)